Likelihood of Success

Ron Coleman’s pretty good blog

Ticket to totalitarianism

Posted by Ron Coleman on November 25, 2007

NewsBusters prints this excerpt from the transcript of NPR’s review of “Redacted” (via Instapundit):

The rape scene has led to a familiar charge, that De Palma is a misogynist who relishes violence against women. . . .
Another charge is that he’s anti-American or anti-troops. But it’s an act of sympathy to suggest that soldiers on their third tours of duty in a place where they have no knowledge of the culture, where they can’t tell who’s on their side and who wants to blow them up, stand a good chance of losing both their moral compass and their minds. Here, and in “Casualties of War,” De Palm[a] is dramatizing the idea that even decent people in such circumstances can convince themselves they’re entitled to do anything.

Here lies the road to the complete inversion of morality. As an “act of sympathy” for the troops, DePalma is supposedly taking the position that even the worst actors in the world — U.S. troops committing atrocities while on an imperialistic mission — are no worse than morally exempt from blame for such atrocities because of the moral incoherence all around them. The logic is unassailable:

  1. Bad guys might be good guys.
  2. Good guys might be bad guys.
  3. Hey, this is hard!
  4. Let’s rape someone.

stalin.jpgThis aligns well with the leftist conception that people the world ’round do not make their own choices at all, but rather are zombies. In America, choiceless voters are under the sway of Rush Limbaugh, religious fundamentalism, and Karl Rove. In the Middle East, suicide bombers are compelled to murder housewives and schoolchildren by their plight or by their rage. But it is relatively novel to see the left apply this to the faceless, heartless automatons of the U.S. military, even in the commission of their fictional outrages. Naturally we can expect NPR to lobby for the release of all soldiers incarcerated for improper conduct in the Iraqi theater immediately.

Soon we will recognize that everything — everything! — is George W. Bush’s fault, and that individual conscience is merely a bourgeois construct of kapital. It is so much simpler.

Cross-posted at Right Wing News.

Advertisements

2 Responses to “Ticket to totalitarianism”

  1. Thankfully, no one is seeing this piece of shit film. (http://www.nypost.com/seven/11252007/gossip/pagesix/de_palma_iraq_flick_bombs_582058.htm). I figured the amount of press this thing is getting, it would have drawn in more curious viewers, but American’s seem to have more sense than that.

  2. Lev said

    Hoorah!
    This is the ONLY picture of Josef Vissarionovich Stalin, imah shmoi vezichroi with TWO Gold Stars.
    Usually he wore only one-for “Socialist Labor” because he was unhappy that he did not take over the world after WWII and Brian De Palma, imah shmoi, could not become “People’s Artist of the Global USSR”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: